There once was a time in the not-too-distant cinematic past when the world was still largely undiscovered, and areas of the planet were a mystery to modern man. What beasts lived on these islands? What creatures were in these jungles? What was out there, lurking in the shadows? 

Steven Spielberg’s game-changing Jurassic Park harbored dinosaurs on a remote Hawaiian island. True, these dinosaurs were cloned, but they were cloned from DNA found in mosquitoes dug up from deep underground in remote jungles. Were those the same jungles that King Kong once ruled?

Trace these stories back far enough, and you end up with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s 1912 novel, The Lost World. It has been adapted directly to cinema five times, and who knows how many more it inspired, but the original (and best) is the 1925 silent version directed by Harry Hoyt—available on Blu-ray from Flicker Alley.

The plot of The Lost World is so simple and so maddeningly stupid that you’ll find yourself cheering for the dinosaurs. Maybe that’s the point. Professor Challenger (Wallace Beery) is convinced that somewhere in the “trackless jungles” of Venezuela, dinosaurs still walk the Earth. This theory is based on a few sketches found in a notebook that Paula White (Bessie Love) gave him. Apparently, that’s good enough for Challenger, and he challenges any man that does not believe him to follow him into that very jungle. A newspaper offers to fund the adventure, and a rag-tag team joins Dr. Challenger and Paula: sportsman Sir John Roxton (Lewis Stone), reporter Edward Malone (Lloyd Hughes), the skeptical professor Summerlee (Arthur Hoyt), the Indian servant Zambor (Jules Cowes in appalling blackface), and Challenger’s butler, Austin (Francis Finch-Smiles).

The characters are one-dimensional (at best), and the plot is barely there, but that’s okay. We come not to see scintillating storytelling. We’re here for dinosaurs.

And thanks to the work of Willis O’Brien, dinosaurs are what we get. O’Brien started working with stop-motion animation as early as 1913, a painstaking process where the illusion of movement is constructed by creating a small figure—usually out of clay—and photographing its movement one frame at a time. When the images are played back at a normal speed (24 frames a second), the figure comes to life and moves before our very eyes. It takes a lot of time and love to make a stop-motion movie, and it shows. 

O’Brien followed up the success of The Lost World with another classic, 1933’s King Kong, and both have remained in good circulation worldwide. Both movies contain wooden acting and dated filmmaking, but the creatures themselves continue to be cherished and loved.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

The Lost World (1925)
Directed by Harry O. Hoyt
Scenario by Marion Fairfax
Based on the novel by Arthur Conan Doyle
Produced by Earl Hudson
Starring: Bessie Love, Lewis Stone, Wallace Beery, Lloyd Hughes, Alma Bennett, Arthur Hoyt, Margaret McWade
First National Pictures, Not rated, Running time 110 minutes, Premiered Feb. 2, 1925

A version of the above review first appeared in the pages of Boulder Weekly Vol. 22, No. 44, “When dinosaurs roamed the land.”